Showing posts with label Sheffield City Schools. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sheffield City Schools. Show all posts

Sunday, July 20, 2025

What Are the Problems in the Sheffield School System?





The Sheffield City school system contains four schools - two elementary, one middle, and one senior high. How much turnover should one expect in these four schools? Here's a short rundown from an insider:

5/14/25 : 11 resignations 4/28/25: 4, including high school assistant principal and district assistant superintendent 3/17/25: 1-Central office secretary/bookkeeper/receptionist 1/30/25: 1 resignation 12/20/25 (emergency meeting): 1 resignation 11/18/24: 2 resignations 10/28/24: 3 resignations including the school district CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER 10/11/24 (Special called meeting): They fired a child nutrition worker. 8/26/24: 1 resignation (bus driver) 7/22/24: 2 resignations 6/24/24: 5 resignations 5/20/24: 4 teachers were TERMINATED. Not allowed to resign, and not non-renewed. (I don’t believe any of these teachers had tenure, and non-tenured teachers can be let go at any time without reason. I’m trying to find out why they were fired. This group consisted of the ISS teacher, a kindergarten teacher, a high school English teacher, and a choir teacher. There were also 6 resignations. 4/29/24: 3 resignations 2/26/24: 3 resignations including the district CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER 9/25/23: 1 resignation 8/28/23: 1 resignation- the Assistant Superintendent 8/4/23: 4 resignations including Junior High Principal 7/10/23: 1 resignation 6/26/23: 1 5/15/23 (special called meeting): 2 TERMINATIONS-a teacher and a nurse in addition to 1 resignation 4/24/23: 4 resignations 3/20/23: 2 resignations 2/27/23: 1 resignation 2/3/23 Emergency meeting: 1 resignation (teacher) 1/23/23: 1 resignation 12/16/22: 2 resignations Board meetings are only archived on the website through October 2022.

Do these figures represent a problem? It would seem so. Comments welcome.




 

Saturday, June 15, 2024

Sheffield Down in the Dumps with Last Place

 



The retention component of the Alabama Literacy Act, passed in 2019, becomes effective with this year's third graders. In simple terms, it means a third grader could be retained, or held back, if the child is not reading on grade level before August 2024.


So how are towns in the Shoals/Northwest Alabama doing? Here's a rundown of passing rate percentages:

Florence - 93
Muscle Shoals - 96.7
Russellville - 92.4
Sheffield - 76.9
Tuscumbia - 95


How do you think Sheffield parents will react if 23.1% of this year's third grade is held back? That's 23 out of every 100 students who are failing their simplest academic subject.

At least Sheffield still has Inspiration Landing...




Tuesday, November 7, 2023

City of Sheffield Schools or SCS District?

 



A Sheffield parent asked us how City of Sheffield schools had the funds to install a Lamar electronic billboard near O'Neal Bridge. The parent also asked why the sign displayed various city landmarks, rather than schools:




These are two very interesting questions; however, this isn't what struck us as odd. In looking at the system's Facebook page, SCS District, we discovered a second page described as un-official, City of Sheffield Schools.

Is there a problem with this? Yes, many people who want to commend or simply mention Sheffield City Schools go to the unofficial page since that's how they intuitively key it in. The SCS District page never sees these commendations/remarks.

Perhaps the Sheffield City Schools page could add the word "unofficial" to its title? 

Returning to the Lamar billboard, we also wonder who paid for the massive electronic sign and why four out of five images have nothing to do with the school system. Readers, any ideas?


*****


Hi, fans! I'm Brooks, a 10 month-old male Poodle/Lab mix. Did you notice my nose is sorta heart-shaped? I'm ready for my next life adventure, not to mention meal, so please come see me at the Florence shelter in the industrial park:



Monday, April 10, 2023

Sheffield City Schools System Has 47 Openings

 



The Sheffield School System is made up of four schools. Currently, 47 job openings are reported within the system. 

A reader has stated: 47 positions, including ALL of the Central Office Staff. I know that non-tenured positions always get reposted each year, but *47* positions in a system the size of SCS in unheard of.

Obviously, education ain't what it used to be...

*****

We may have an idea on what precipitated this dramatic exodus from Sheffield schools - faculty and staff are tired of having to run the gauntlet of trash to arrive at their jobs each day.


Three Weeks & Counting on 32nd Street


Tuesday, December 13, 2022

A Parent Speaks on Sheffield Schools

 



Something in the Water?



Let me preface this by saying, as last time, the MAJORITY of Sheffield parents do a tremendous job raising their children. However, there appears to be a VERY VOCAL MINORITY among Sheffield parents, whose actions go a long ways toward explaining 'why' Sheffield's schools are rumored to be having massive issues with student discipline. Why the school system refuses to address this issue remains a mystery.


For example: Last week there was rumored to have been a 'knock down, drag out' fight in the lobby of Sheffield High School. This fight wasn't between students, but rather between the parents of students alleged to have been involved in a fight. Reportedly, both parents were arrested on unknown charges, but I imagine 'disorderly conduct' would have been a good place to start.


And then there are the parents that are allegedly complaining about the Sheffield Police Department 'running radar' in the system's School Zones. This is ostensibly being done due to SAFETY ISSUES created by the very parents of students being brought to school. What parents in their right minds WOULDN'T want this? Well....this IS Sheffield.


If these instances don't illustrate issues that SHOULD be priority issues for the school system, perhaps a NEW school board is in order.


Anonymous Parent

Tuesday, December 6, 2022

Sheffield City Schools Giving Away Money?

 



From a Sheffield resident:


SCS recently announced that 'employees returning in January' would receive a $150(P/T)-$300(F/T) payment for 'services yet to be received' for all of their 'hard work this year'. Employees not planning on returning in January will receive nothing, regardless of their hard work so far this school year. 

This follows an earlier decision (slap in the face?) by the SCS's school board to withdraw a previously-approved raise for the system's School Nurses.

Are things so bad in Sheffield's schools that the school board thinks(?) it has to BRIBE employees to stay?

'Merry Christmas you filthy animals!'


*****

No matter what the school system may call this, it's basically a retention bonus. Is it legal? We believe that it is, but as our reader says, it's a bit of a slap in the face to those who choose to leave.

We hear that a great many are choosing to leave the Sheffield system. This should be a wake-up call to the school board that something is very wrong...somewhere.


*****


Another reader has pointed out a very lackadaisical attitude in the Sheffield system. Perhaps it's the system's way of saying their students will one day turn the world upside down:



Wednesday, November 16, 2022

Assaults, Feces, & Malfeasance at Sheffield Schools

 



Part II of one reader's take on the current condition of Sheffield City Schools:


As mentioned earlier, people in Sheffield had a right to expect great things from their new Superintendent of Schools. Unfortunately, this hasn't been the case. It seems to all boil down to one thing: Sheffield isn't *like* the other towns in The Shoals. I don't know if it's something in the water, but things are *different*.

How different? Apparently Sheffield students think it is perfectly OK to:

Hit, kick, and bite faculty and staff. It is even rumored that Dr. Nelson has been a victim of such behavior.

'Finger paint' with feces on the bathroom walls.

Scream profanities at faculty and staff. Even the SROs aren't immune to such uncivilized behavior.

Get the idea? Now to be perfectly fair and transparent, MOST of Sheffield's students are great, as are their parents. However, these ’problem children' appear to come by it honestly. They are simply mirroring behaviors that their 'parents', and I hesitate using that word, deem acceptable. That MUST change. If it doesn't, SCS will lose its wonderful students, caring and involved parents, and its dedicated, but beleaguered faculty and staff.

And it is THERE that the problem truly lies: SCS, the Superintendent of Schools, AND the Board of Education are OUT OF TOUCH WITH REALITY. They *think* that what works in other systems will work in Sheffield's schools. It won't. At least NOT until the 'problem PARENTS' are held accountable. Things ARE different here....and NOT in a *good* way.


Vacancies at Sheffield City Schools


Wednesday, June 8, 2022

No New Sheffield School Asst. Superintendent?

 



A source close to the Sheffield superintendent's office has stated there are no current plans to fill the now vacant position of assistant superintendent. Will it be filled later after Dr. Carlos Nelson has sufficient time to improve the workings of the system...or will others simply take up the slack?

*****

The Republican steering committee has scheduled the next hearing on the election challenges for June 25th. That's four days after the election and much too late for the contests involved.

We can hope only for the committee to go forward in its investigation on how the ballot mix-up came to be and then report to the Lauderdale County District Attorney's office if needed.

*****

In the ongoing saga of Tre Srygley, his charges now include Attempted Murder. This does answer the question as to why his bond is set at 150K. We can't recall when we've seen so much victim blaming.

No matter what any woman has done in her past, she doesn't deserve to be repeatedly strangled and beaten. Let's all try to remember that, shall we?



Sunday, May 8, 2022

Is it the Sheffield School Board's Fault?

 



Last week Listerhill gave EVERY STUDENT at each Sheffield school a FREE pair of NEW tennis shoes PLUS 5 pairs of socks. FREE! Would you believe some ungrateful parents actually showed up at the school, making total asses out of themselves, because they didn't like the 'color, brand, style, etc' tennis shoes that their kid(s) received?!?! 

UNreal! Only in Sheffield is such behavior ALLOWED to happen. This issue falls SQUARELY in the laps of a DEAF school board.




Thursday, March 31, 2022

Will Dr. Carlos Nelson Finally Be Sheffield School Super?

 



For the past nine years Dr. Carlos Nelson has been Deputy Superintendent of Sheffield City Schools. During that time, he has been bypassed twice for the super's position. 

First, the Sheffield Board of Education saw fit to hire Keith Lankford. During Dr. Lankford's time at the helm, he mainly promoted Inspiration Landing and looked for a better position. He lasted three years.

Then came Keith Davis who was, judging from our e-mails, almost universally disliked for his waffling and pandering personality. He's also lasted three years.

Dr. Nelson is certainly more than qualified and, more importantly, not about to go running off for a number of years. This is his home. If Sheffield doesn't promote Dr. Nelson this time, what new incompetence will the next three years see?



Thursday, November 18, 2021

Sheffield City Schools - Part II





Sheffield City Schools have for decades relied on a fund set up by Sheffield businessman L. E. Willson. Now questions have arisen about the stability of this fund...or even its continued existence. Here's a brief history of the fund from a Sheffield historian:


Col. L.E. Willson was a wealthy businessman who was originally from Kansas. After WWI, he somehow ended up in Sheffield where he bought the Tennessee Sand & Gravel Company as well as Arrow Transportation, the largest barge company that ran on the Tennessee River at that time. He was a HUGE supporter of education, and he contributed to several school and scholarship funds in various places. 

However, when he died in the 60s, the bulk of his estate went to Sheffield City Schools. It did not go to L.E. Willson or any other individual school. Instead, it was left with the directive that the money be used to fund Sheffield teachers in their pursuits of postgraduate degrees. Willson had already provided the funding for school trips, technological advances, and other projects that directly benefited Sheffield’s schools and students while he was alive. His will stated that from that point forward, he wanted Sheffield to be able to hire and keep the best teachers, and he thought that the best way to do that was to pay for all advanced degrees. 

The interest accrued from Willson’s gift was the source of the funding. There was a stipulation that the principal was never to be touched. The money COULD NOT be used for any purpose other than teachers’ advanced degrees, per Willson’s will.

Col. Willson had given so much money that the initial gift, along with accrued interest, should have never run out. The depletion of the Col. Willson fund began with Dr. Roger Tomberlin. He somehow found a loophole that justified his paying for running fiber optic cables throughout the school system with money from that fund. 

Teachers’ graduate degrees stopped being paid for during Keith Lankford's tenure. It paid for every teacher’s degree from 1965 until Lankford arrived in 2015. It was then allegedly gone within three years. Teachers’ graduate degrees simply stopped being paid for during Lankford's years here.


We would advise any interested and concerned citizens in Sheffield to ask to see the financial records for this fund. It might not bring any of the money back, but at least the public would know where it went.





 

Wednesday, November 17, 2021

Sheffield City Schools - Part I

 



What is the condition of the Sheffield City School System, and, perhaps more importantly, how did it get there? First a look at what the system once was, as per a confidential source:


Despite the snarky remarks from the three surrounding city school districts, Sheffield was at one time the crown jewel of education in the Shoals. Many Colbert County physicians, lawyers, and businessmen moved to Sheffield specifically for the purpose of sending their children to school there. I can’t tell you the number of English professors at UNA who could accurately identify Sheffield graduates based strictly off the essays they had written. The first major crack in the system happened in 1988 when Superintendent Carl Boley retired, and the board hired Dr. Roger Tomberlin. While he was successful in securing funding for technology updates, he will only be remembered for closing the neighborhood elementary schools and consolidating all of them into Threadgill. 

Two major things resulted from that decision, and they changed the course of the whole school system and city. First, the demographics of Sheffield changed. Many of the professionals who had chosen to live in either the Village or Rivermont moved out of the city because C.M. Brewster Elementary School had closed. The tax base dropped drastically when these bank presidents, doctors, lawyers, and engineers left. 

The second major shift involved L.E. Willson. That school had always been a true middle school that housed all of Sheffield’s sixth, seventh, and eighth graders. To my knowledge, Willson had always had a principal, assistant principal, a bookkeeper, and a separate secretary. In fact, as recently as 2016, there were two ladies in the office there who shared secretarial and bookkeeping responsibilities. When Threadgill was forced to take in all of the students from the other schools that Tomberlin closed, it was renamed as a primary school (grades Pre-K through 2), and Willson became an elementary school that served grades three through six. The board voted to build a brand new junior high that would be connected to the high school. It’s my understanding that Willson’s veteran teachers who had the certification to teach both middle and elementary grades were given the choice of moving to the new junior high or staying at Willson. A handful moved into the shiny new building when it opened in 1994, and many of those who stayed soon became very envious of their former co-workers who were now getting the latest computers and textbooks while they were being told to make do with what they had. 

Thus began the great schism between L.E. Willson and the junior high. Willson’s principal at that time, Mike Owens, began promoting and lobbying for his school BIG TIME, and when Owens made a move to the central office a year or so later, he made sure that Willson got the first and best of everything. Since the mid 1990s, L.E. Willson was held up as THE example that the other schools should follow, especially when it came to test scores. Willson was the school to beat. best of everything. 

The fact that Willson is now facing a shortage of subs and other necessary items due to a lack of money tells me that the school system is in SERIOUS trouble. Carlos Nelson (assistant superintendent) has been passed over twice for the superintendent’s job. I’m sure that’s why he insisted on a raise after he learned that Stephanie Weiseman was making more money as a high school principal. 

I’m hearing that the teachers are being told to conserve as much energy as possible. On the record, it’s because of the energy conservation “partnership” with Sheffield Utilities, but Sheffield Utilities also serves all of the county schools, and they’re not pushing this conservation thing. My guess is that Sheffield is out of money. As for the sub shortage, that’s happening everywhere. However, Sheffield’s lack of disciple enforcement at the central office has lead to people not wanting to sub there. 

The money problems began with Keith Lankford. Before he came to town, Dr. Tim Morgan was superintendent. He was EXTREMELY prudent with finances. He started a faculty advisory committee in which one teacher from every school in the system met jointly with him at least once a month to discuss issues at hand. Every time they met, Dr. Morgan would lay out a spreadsheet with the system’s finances on it. Before he approached the board with any purchases, he presented them first and asked teachers to go back and discuss them with respective faculties and staff. Morgan always said that he liked to maintain enough surplus to run the school system for eighteen months without any federal or state funds in case of an unexpected proration. Dr. Richard Gardner before him had practiced the same thing. 

Sheffield schools were in excellent financial shape until Lankford got here. That eighteen month surplus was gone by the end of his first year, and it doesn’t look like they have ever recovered. I’m hearing that Davis has spent a small fortune on Chromebooks. The swift and thorough discipline that had always existed in Sheffield’s schools disappeared as soon as Lankford entered the picture. 

Lankford re-wrote the student handbook code of conduct. Allow me to rephrase; he literally took pages from Jefferson County’s student handbook (his former employer) and put them inside Sheffield’s student handbook. There were sections that literally read “Jefferson County Schools” in students’ handbooks. Kids were getting away with behavior that had NEVER been tolerated in Sheffield before. That’s part of the reason why so many teachers began resigning as well as why subs began refusing jobs in Sheffield. The ONLY thing that’s going to save this school system (and city) is to have a thorough audit and investigation from OUTSIDE agencies. Until that happens, money, enrollment, population, and morale will continue to dwindle.


Tomorrow: The legacy of L.E. Willson



Tuesday, May 4, 2021

Exodus of Sheffield School Personnel?

 



We've received several communications concerning the state of Sheffield City Schools. These range from non-support of resource officers to failing to back up teachers in decisions relating to discipline. There have also been reports of Davis' impromptu admin meetings causing disruption in both the classroom and the offices. 

We know some teachers and support staff are seeking other employment...if they haven't abandoned ship already. That brings us to the assistant superintendent.

At the time Keith Davis was hired as Sheffield's new super, many felt the position should have gone to Dr. Carlos Nelson. Many even went as far as to report to us that he was not offered the position due to race. Dr. Nelson handled this well, as we're told he does most situations. He has applied for other positions; rest assured he will at some point leave. What happens then?

You may remember that Dr. Keith Davis was terminated from his previous position. That didn't deter Sheffield from hiring him. Now there seems to be a great deal of buyers' remorse. 

The Sheffield City School Board needs to make some decisions at this point. The public is watching...



Wednesday, April 14, 2021

Is Sheffield City Schools' Vaccine Policy Legal?

 



We've been sent the following information concerning Sheffield City Schools:

SCS BOE recently voted to DENY federal relief funds to any employee that refuses to be vaccinated and later contracts COVID.

First, we'll assume this is true. Second, is it legal?

That would have to be decided in the courts; however, there is an established legal precedent concerning flu vaccines. Anyone working in a large public endeavor (hospital or school) may be legally required to be vaccinated unless they have a valid medical excuse or can prove they have religious objections.

Our advice would be to find another job where you're in no danger of infecting innocent people if you refuse to be vaccinated.



Sunday, October 18, 2020

A Visit to Sheffield Schools

 


Remember when Supt. Keith Davis extended SCS hours (allegedly because of reduced contact time) and failed to get board approval? Well...SCS has returned to normal, in-person, 5-day a week schooling, but....the extended hours haven't been changed back to normal.


Latest school improvement plan:











Friday, May 15, 2020

Davis & Goldberg: Why Education Gets a Bad Name




A source in Sheffield schools tells us there are currently ten teaching vacancies in the small system...and that's not counting other personnel vacancies. Most are seriously disenchanted with the current superintendent Keith Davis. It may not be a problem; we hear that many students are opting to go elsewhere in the fall.


There's a new visiting prof at Auburn. Dr. Jesse A. Goldberg from New York has announced he won't be using the greeting "War Eagle." He doesn't like the word "war." The professor of black and queer studies (his term, not ours) also wants to abolish prisons. Boy, did he come to the wrong state.

Actually, we're just surprised UNA didn't snap him up. He seems like an improvement on vising rapists.



Monday, March 30, 2020

Unrest in Sheffield City Schools



Subtitle: What Is Keith Davis Thinking?!!!

When Gov. Ivey closed brick and mortar schools for the term, we (silly us) thought that she meant the schools were closed. Apparently Sheffield Superintendent Keith Davis didn't quite see it that way. He almost immediately introduced plans for a "day camp" for children aged 6 to 12 whose parents were essential crisis employees.

Official policy has stated that sick children will not be allowed. We have to ask: If most children are asymptomatic of the "plague," how will anyone know who is infected and who isn't?

Yet, this is not the reason for the most recent Mt. St. Sheffield eruption of irate teachers. No, it seems Supt. Davis now wants all teachers in place in their rooms to teach remotely. Again, silly us, have we misunderstood the meaning of the word "quarantine" all these years?

According to an informed source, the AEA has been called in. Good! If ever any teachers needed backup, it would seem to be the ones in the Sheffield system. 

What in the world is Davis thinking? Ah, political posturing...you gotta love it!



Monday, September 30, 2019

Sheffield Board of Education


First, let's keep expenses low: "Few, if any, teacher applicants with more than 5 years of teaching experience are getting interviews."

Then, let's keep it in the family: "Did you know that Sheffield’s board of education has another new member? David Myrick stepped down, and Titian Scales replaced him. Not a word of that has been mentioned in the Times Daily. Oh-Titian’s husband is the son of City council member Malea Scales. She replaced her husband, Gary Scales, after he committed suicide in 2018."

Oh, and we saved you the trouble: We looked at Titian's photo on Facebook, and, no, she doesn't. Go figure...



Sunday, March 4, 2018

Sheffield School Safety/Illegal Upskirts?


From a reader:

Are Russ Corey and Lisa Singleton-Rickman reporters, or are they running PR for the city of Sheffield and its school system? I’m referring to today’s article about school safety, which of course, begins with the worship of Keith Lankford and and a rundown of his accomplishments. NOT ONCE does the article mention that parents flooded the school with visits and phone calls this past Tuesday due to the high school’s failure to follow protocol.


*****



*****

Apparently "upskirts" are not currently illegal in Alabama if they're taken in a public place. The legislature may soon change that, making it a misdemeanor if taken for personal "enjoyment" or a felony if posted publicly. 

Good idea? Certainly! Yet we're seeing comments (we assume from men) who see nothing wrong with this. In other words, they're saying if you don't want upskirt pics, don't wear a skirt. Really?

For anyone who needs a geographic check, yes, this is still Alabama...





Saturday, December 23, 2017

Gemstone Foods & Sheffield Schools: Two Sketchy Institutions?


Gemstone Foods is being lauded as they have announced the purchase and opening the old Hillshore Farms plant for a rendering facility. The Mayor of Florence and others have spoken highly of this project to replace Hillshire Farms that previously operated at the same location.

However, in the quest for public officials to burnish their resumes with economic development they have failed to totally examine Gemstone's background. Gemstone has been operating in AL since 2013.

Gemstone Foods was found to owe 595 employees more than $140,000 in back wages and damages after the U.S. Department of Labor investigation found overtime violations at the chicken-cutting company’s two Decatur facilities.

In June 2017, the state department of labor fined Gemstone $64,200 for violations related to a dozen teen workers at its McEntire Lane facility. The youngest was 13.

The teens’ documentation showed large discrepancies in age, “so egregious that a layperson could identify these documents were forged,” according to an Alabama Department of Labor report.

Violations:

1) Employees were paid two different rates for hours worked. The employer did not use the weighted average in calculating overtime for employees who earned multiple rates of pay in an overtime workweek.

2) Gemstone claimed an overtime exemption for an employee who was determined to be non-exempt.

3) Gemstone employed minors under the age of 18, in violation of child labor regulations. There were multiple violations related to a 13-year-old worker and three 15-year-olds.

Besides $140,122 in back wages and damages, Gemstone had civil penalties worth $7,865.

Gemstone stated the overtime calculation error has been addressed, and employees were paid $70,061.40 in back wages and $70,061.40 in damages.

The Alabama Department of Labor’s investigation found “occurrences of identity concealment” related to the teens in employee files.

The investigation found one employee file had a doctor’s excuse with the child’s legal name, but a supervisor had written his work name on the back and signed so that it would be put in the correct file.

Gemstone CEO and President Heath Loyd has said that Gemstone will invest over $11 million and has committed to hiring 296 employees. The company is optimistic about possibly rehiring some of the previous workforce from Hillshire and working with the Shoals community to staff the plant. The company will pay competitive and comparable wages to similar employers in the area and slightly higher in terms of poultry processing compensation. Gemstone wants to become a contributing member of the community and has partnered with the City of Florence and SEDA for support.


Southern Son

*****

*****

And from a reader:

A couple of years ago, right after Keith Lankford rode into town, HPBC pastor Brett Pittman published a video on YouTube in which he stated that he had met with “educational leaders” in Sheffield, and they were beginning a partnership that would allow members of HPBC to provide tutoring services to the underprivileged children of Sheffield. Folks in Sheffield went nuts in outrage, and nothing ever came of it. Of course, Lankford denied having any knowledge of Pittman’s claims of meeting with Sheffield “educational leaders”. 

This was also approximately the same time that Brian Lindsey sold the section 8 apartments connecting to Sheffield’s Threadgill Primary School that he had owned for several years. I believe Sheffield police had to respond to those apartments a few times due to some residents at that time being engaged in drug activity. Since then Lankford highjacked the local churches’ Thanksgiving offering and started STIC, Students Tutored in Churches. 

As for Sheffield’s board of education, not a single member has a child or grandchild who attends a Sheffield school. Steve Hargrove has already purchased land in Muscle Shoals in preparation for moving out of Sheffield after he retires.

*****

Note: We're always happy to publish readers' opinions on issues. Sometimes we're totally unfamiliar with the issues; other times we have a rudimentary knowledge of the situation and appreciate the viewpoints of others. We attempt to give the Shoals a voice. Rebuttals are always welcome.