Showing posts with label Florence Parking Deck. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Florence Parking Deck. Show all posts

Thursday, January 30, 2025

RIP “Original” Parking Deck

 



Natural Death or Murder?


The “execution” papers were signed on Tuesday, January 28th, 2025. The executioner will be a company out of Birmingham named Tomlin Excavating which will provide the wrecking ball to finally put the old girl out of her misery. She was abused, neglected, and even set on fire but could not withstand a fight with city hall. The “original” parking deck is coming down.

There were a lot of pieces to the puzzle that finally put together the parking deck’s demise, but in this writer's opinion, the best interest of city hall politicians and not the best interest of the Florence taxpayers is what this situation has been about all along. It was decided almost 10 years ago by a “so-called” previous administration that this town needed to build a new parking deck or two to go along with the new city hall complex. Now bear in mind, at the time of this “decision” this “previous” administration had 4 of the current 6 people sitting on the council podium at the time who are STILL there. 1 on the council then, Andy Betterton is now mayor and Dick Jordan, the actual power behind the throne, is dead. But it seems his influence in governing lives on. Let me give you my take on the two parking decks and of one's untimely demise.

The mayor at the time, Steve Holt, had the good political and common sense to know that you could not spring too much on the taxpayer at once. After all, there was still improvements to be made to the sportsplex. But, as I said, the real power behind the throne, Dick Jordan and his “friends” around town, had other ideas on how they wanted to see the downtown area revised. They were throwing a bone to East Florence in the promise of an “Entertainment District” and a federally funded roundabout at Royal Ave and Huntsville Rd but if they got too aggressive with distributing tax money downtown where most of his pals owned the buildings that would benefit from TWO new parking decks, it would not be a good look. Of course, there was also the question of how to transfer the ECM property that the city had just had returned to their purview. 

Ol' Dick had a deal he wanted to go through with his “bestie” Joel Anderson who would get the property for practically nothing and then build a retail complex with the taxpayer footing the bill, but they would somehow have to sneak that in without too much attention being drawn. It would boost the property value of the shopping center his family had owned for decades on College St. Just the right amount of finesse was needed to make the plan work. Then a pandemic happened in the middle of a city election. Also, there were national issues that were getting played out locally and it seemed like the citizens of Florence were more interested in the national evening news than anything going on locally.

Sure enough, there were very few candidates who ran in each district for the election. And of the two candidates in the mayor's race, it really did not matter who won because they were both part of the regime. The “winner” was the more malleable of the two so Dick and friends had everything in place. The plan to spend millions on parking decks for the downtown area, a new city hall complex that could possibly be named for Dick Jordan and the plans for a shopping center/luxury housing complex on the former ECM property just sailed right through when it was time for the council to vote. The public either didn’t notice or didn’t care and it was all but a done deal. Things moved along and Dick even selected his replacement without an election and had him installed to implement this plan before he left the council. He eventually met the grim reaper. RIP Dick Jordan, everything was in place.

There were a few things that had been “accomplished” under the “Jordan” administration that have had lasting effects on the city of Florence. Some were good like the sportsplex, many were questionable. But the one that actually effected every single citizen of Florence the most was the rise in sales tax. Over Dick’s time from councilman to mayor to council president the sales tax had risen from 6% to 9.5%. This last raise which occurred during his time as president of the council, would be the one to put the downtown project over the top! It was supposed to be a raise in the sales tax to support higher salaries for firefighters and police. The police chief at the time, Ron Tyler had appeared before the council at a meeting and in no uncertain terms let the city know if something was not done about the pay there would be many officers leaving for areas which paid more. Some questioned this and even at the time the remarks from the public were mainly against this move. There is a video recording of this meeting on the Facebook page, Florence city council Vote Em All Out and I highly recommend everyone who is reading this to go to the page and find the recording and watch it. The fact that with this sales tax hike Florence would be paying the highest rate in North Alabama, higher than Huntsville or Decatur, was also discussed. As planned it seems, the agenda item was passed and the sales tax was raised. And it was not written in the resolution what this tax hike revenue would be used exclusively for so, there would be money to burn in the city coffers!

And all of that brings us back to the “original” parking deck and its demise. The original plan for the “city hall complex” going back about 10 years was to have a 6-story city hall complex and TWO parking decks. Build one at the corner of Tombigbee and Pine Streets and tear down the “original” at Tennessee and Pine. Instead of the larger 500+ parking space version like the “original” there would be two at around 300 spaces each. That way, the city employees could use one during “normal business hours” as had been the practice since “original” had been built and there would be another for retail shoppers and downtown business employees to use.

But there appeared a catch. After the pandemic, building prices soared. When the feelers were sent out to construction companies for bid amounts of how much it would cost to build the entire city hall and parking decks complex, they came back at twice what was originally planned. There was another problem. The original parking deck was starting to show what would happen to a structure if it had no maintenance for 40 or so years. Maintenance of buildings had never been a high priority in the city. The recreation center buildings are old and for the most part over the years just left alone to the elements. Most of the “maintenance” staff were actually yard crews. The parks are what the maintenance was all about.

The engineering firm, LBYD engineering out of Huntsville, back in 2018, had submitted a study paid for by the city that showed the current parking deck was in need of upgrades and repairs. This is sort of like an estimate from a roofing company on someone’s home. It is unclear whether it was deliberate or through negligence but from 2018 until the present day there was no maintenance done on the parking deck at the corner of Tennessee and Pine Streets. And it was starting to show. The study was ignored and no repairs made. And something needed to be done.

So, at this the mayor’s office went to work with a public relations campaign to turn lemons into lemonade. They had a piece of concrete that supposedly had fallen from the ceiling on one of the floors on the deck and a call was made to all the Huntsville television stations and of course a press release was written for the Times Daily to use to broadcast far and wide that the deck is falling apart. THE DECK IS FALLING! It is dangerous and must be replaced and come down as soon as possible. AND also, they would announce they had a plan for a shiny new deck to be built! The parking count at first was never given, but when the price tag came in at almost 30% higher than had been discussed in the original city hall complex plan in 2018, they had to gloss over the actual parking space count. It wasn’t smaller. It was MORE COMPACT! It had biking spaces! 

And it appeared the public would never be the wiser. Until some citizens questioned what was actually going on. And from there this tale of the original parking deck will end. The comedic tale of grief is not for the parking deck itself but for the situation this area has allowed itself to get into where the citizens are blindly led by the nose in whatever direction an elected official wants to take them and the lazy and complicit traditional news media leads without question. If it were not for social media sites such as Shoalanda and others, a complete propaganda pipeline would be all that people had available for local political news. Some think local events do not matter in their daily lives. I contend most vehemently that is not the case. This sentiment was relayed to me many years ago by a local political observer and I will end with it: WHAT HAPPENS ON PINE STREET CAN AFFECT YOUR EVERYDAY LIFE MUCH MORE THAN WHAT HAPPENS ON PENNSYLVANIA AVE.







Sunday, December 15, 2024

EVs in the New Parking Garage?

 



The old and new Florence parking decks have produced endless discussions. We've only now learned of an important argument that has been taking place, one that may be already settled. The question: Is the current City policy the correct one?

Electric vehicles are not allowed in some decks. Why?


Electric vehicles (EVs) can potentially set parking decks on fire due to the risk of their lithium-ion batteries experiencing "thermal runaway" in certain situations, which can lead to intense heat generation, rapid fire spread, and difficult-to-extinguish fires, especially in confined spaces like parking garages; this is a growing concern as more EVs are on the road, and proper fire safety measures are crucial in parking structures to mitigate this risk.

Key points about EV fires in parking decks:
Thermal runaway:
The primary danger is the potential for a battery to overheat and enter a "thermal runaway" state, where it rapidly releases large amounts of heat, causing a fire that can spread quickly to nearby vehicles.

Toxic smoke:
EV battery fires produce highly toxic smoke due to the chemicals involved, posing a significant health hazard.

Difficult to extinguish:
Traditional firefighting methods may not be effective against an EV battery fire, requiring large volumes of water and specialized techniques to cool the battery down.

Confinement issues:
Parking garages are often tightly packed with vehicles, which can accelerate fire spread if an EV catches fire.

Charging station risks:
Faulty charging stations or improper charging practices can also increase the risk of an EV fire in a parking structure.


Yet the powers that be in Florence are currently allowing EVs in the new deck without specialized means to avoid/mitigate these fires. Perhaps it's simply a case of Andy being Andy...



Thursday, December 5, 2024

Chicken Little: THE PARKING DECK IS FALLING

 



This appeared on my phone text at 3:30 p.m. on Weds. 12/4:




Being confused I called my city hall source and was told this concerned a letter that Mayor Andy Betterton had sent the council from the engineering firm, LBYD Engineering. This is the firm from Huntsville that was hired in 2018 and compiled a report showing the work that needed to be done to the structure of the parking deck at Tennessee and Pine St. This letter had been sent from the chief engineer Ashley Cardin and stated that the deck was in such bad shape that it could pose a safety threat. The notice made it sound like this meeting was being called due to the parking deck falling to the ground or something.


Fortunately, that was not the case, and the meeting was kind of overblown. The sky wasn’t falling, and neither was the parking deck. This is the video recorded by David Carson on his Facebook page; Florence, Alabama Open Meeting Project, of the meeting:




You will notice that Jimmy Oliver latched onto the phrase from the LBDY engineering letter “life safety concern”. If Andy Betterton was playing the part of Chicken Little in this “nursery school drama” Jimmy Oliver sounded like Henny Penny from the fable sounding the alarm. QUICK, RUN FOR YOUR LIFE! The parking deck is falling. It was a little dramatic. At first it seemed all the council were going along with the tale of the dangerous parking deck. And then Blake Edwards spoke. He asked the mayor if the engineer who wrote the letter had inspected the deck recently. Betterton said no, he had just made a phone call to Mr. Cardin asking for a letter on the assumption that no repairs had been done since the inspection. 

It seems Betterton is determined to see the deck demolished. You could tell some on the council knew they had been deceived but it was too late to back out. And the truth is the parking deck is in bad shape, in places. I recently walked the entire structure to see for myself. It does have cracked foundation supports and exposed rusted rebar but that is primarily confined to the top two floors that I saw. But I am not a structural engineer. I was just going by what was visible. Thank goodness, I didn’t get hit in the head with any falling chunks of concrete. I think.

The bottom line to this story is that neglect caused the parking deck at Tennessee St, and Pine to deteriorate and for some unknown reason the previous mayor and council and the current mayor and council chose to ignore the findings in the engineering report and let the deck rot before it’s time. The “original” parking deck at the corner of Tennessee St. and Pine will close at 5 p.m. on Friday 12/6/2024. Chicken Little, Henny Penny and the rest of the barnyard would do well to be more interested in taking care of the buildings we have now than trying to impress the king of tourism and other metropolitan areas. $95.75 million taxpayer dollars in debt is not chicken feed!


The Florence Detective